I'm looking to buy a mini for work. I've come across a 2011 countryman D with 98000 which is Cat S that might be suitable. The other motor I have my eye on is a clubman one D 2014 with 60000 + on the clock. Countryman is £4650 and clubman just under £9K. I love the quirky styling of the clubman. Trying to balance budget, running costs and aesthetics.
Can anyone suggest to me any reason to give either a body swerve? Id be running the length and breadth of Aberdeen. Perhaps a diesel not the ideal car for mostly town driving? For economy is there any particular model I should consider. £9K max budget since I'm not trading in my roadster.

Any advice appreciated.
Sheila